The Narnia Debate Wraps Up
September 6, 2010 in JibeNow Debate by Brian JM

Image from Wikimedia. Used under the GNU Free Documentation License. And also from Vladimir Dzhuvinov, www.ImagesFromBulgaria.com
For me, one of the most special things about JibeNow is the willingness to discuss and scrutinize without offense. The Narnian debate was a great example of how the JibeNow community is basically willing to talk about anything that people are interested in, and do it in a polite manor.
The Question
Mostly due to the crusade of the @DunveganHighlander, a long discussion began on the merits of C.S. Lewis’ Chronicles of Narnia. That lead to the question:
Is Narnia acceptable entertainment for Christians?
Lots of questions came out of this: Is Aslan the initiator of pagan deities or a representation of Jesus Christ? Are Lewis’ struggles with the occult dangerous to readers? “Salvation through Paganism”? Is Lewis saying God isn’t omnipresent? Whoa! Should Christians even be trying to tell allegories? These and more all were discussed.
The Action
This debate lasted much longer than anticipated (yes, we’re all busy). But you can still catch the action and get into the discussion. Some of you might have noticed that if you go back to the original narnia debate post, all the posts in the debate are at the bottom under “trackbacks.” Still; here’s is a list of all the official posts from our debaters:
- The Highlander’s intro is available at The Outer Hebrides: “Is Narnia Acceptable Entertainment for Christians?” Here he outlines the various episodes that make Narnia an inappropriate source of entertainment from a Christian worldview.
- In just three points, Richard’s summary on The Gentlemanly Adventurer outlines why he took the negative position.
- The affirmative position was more fleshed out in the much longer post: The Chronicles of Narnia: First Negative Rebuttal
- Richard’s final post was a much longer look at Narnia in his affirmative rebuttal.
- And just this Saturday, the debate concluded with Nathan’s Negative Summary.
Thank you both for your contributions. But don’t feel it’s over. If you’ve thought of something new, you can engage in the discussion.
Let’s do it again!
Did you know that JibeNow has a Debate group? Go to the JibeNow Debates group, join, and tell me what topics you’re interested in, if you’d be interested in officially representing a side, etc. So far, we’ve debated Entertainment, Texas Secession, Global Warming, and Narnia. There’s still lots of room for more!
We need you to get the next debate on the road. Ready to get started?











“We are perishing for want of wonder, not for want of wonders.” ~G.K. Chesterton ~~~~~~~~~~~~ Thinking about this while biting an apple. Seriously. God didn’t have to make apples so delicious, but He did, and they are nearly fantastic. (nearly fantastic in the sense that it’s so wonderful it seems as though it ought to [...]